A short biography by John M Evans. Part 4

Now Shankara turns to the central technique of his philosophy, the action of burrowing beneath the mind’s mental contents by the practice of intelligent enquiry. There is no blankness here, but a determined assault on the citadel of the ego using all of man’s faculties.

“Who is your wife? Who is your son? Supremely wonderful indeed is this (world). Of whom are you? From where have you come? O brother, think of that truth here.”

There is a method much used in India whereby the meditator deals with various aspects of himself, the mind, the feelings &c, and realizes that they are not actually HIM (or her). It is sometimes called neti neti, or ‘not this, not this.’ In some form it has also been used in Hua Yen Buddhism and elsewhere. However, a modern advocate of Advaita, Ramana Maharshi, believed that the system merely played around within the mind, creating more and more imaginings at the psychological level. He recommended the method of ’self-enquiry’ which aimed at focusing awareness directly at the ‘point’ where thoughts of ‘I’, and hence the ego, begin. The answer then comes from beyond the mind and not, as in the case of neti neti, from the intellect.

Nevertheless, as Ramana was always prepared to point out, most concentrative methods would, in the end, come round to a form of self-enquiry - it just took longer, that was all. The difference then is in the answer. More particularly, from whence that answer comes!

Most sages will advise students to keep good company. The presence of a master, or at least other committed path-seekers, is held to be essential, especially for beginners. Shankara was no exception.

Through the company of the good, there arises non-
attachment..
.
It is with higher minds around you, that you can persist in your efforts to rise above samsara, the world of birth and death. Scriptures and good books are of great value, but the greatest aid of all is the presence of a living, enlightened master.

O Distracted one!…Is there not for you the One who
commands?…it is the association-with-good-people
alone that can serve as a boat to cross the sea of
change.

This stanza sometimes includes the query, ‘Why dissipate mentally over the lips of your lady?’ When we look outwards, we leave the Reality. When we look inwards, we leave the world. This is the paradox of the Advaitins.

Dressing up, playing the holy man, working on our very Western neuroses about Identity, are not the answers to our suffering. They are mere psychological fixes, a patchwork of cheap darns to keep us functioning in a way never intended.

One ascetic with matted locks, one with a shaven
head, one with hairs pulled out one by one, another
parading in his ochre robes - these are fools who,
though seeing, do not see. Indeed, these different
disguises or apparels are only for their belly’s sake.

Strong stuff for a teacher in India, the land of wandering sadhus and ash-smeared fakirs. Again Shankara reminds us of the Buddha, with his ‘Middle Way’ between asceticism and sensuousness. ‘All is vanity, all is vanity.’

True renunciation is not the sacrifice of all the things of the world, but the rejection of the ego-mind which projects its fancies on such things.

The song then returns to the contemplator’s enquiry into the subject in himself.

Who are you? Who am I? From where did I come? Who
is my mother? Who is my father?…

Again we are asked to delve into the depths and examine our consciousness and the space within it and the objects it contains. Who are they? What relationship have I to them? Who on earth am I?

…Thus enquire, leaving aside the entire world-of-
experience, which is essenceless (empty) and a mere
dreamland, born of imagination.

This enquiry prompts an equanimity of mind, an even-temperedness which in itself is necessary for spiritual accomplishments. Hence self-enquiry and stillness go hand in hand. Indeed, they cannot exist without each other.

Strive not, waste not your energy to fight against
or to make friends with your enemy, friend, son, or
relative. Seek the Self everywhere…

And, in the words of the Gita, ‘Who sees all beings in his own Self, and his own Self in all beings, loses all fear.’

Leaving desire, anger, greed, and delusion,
the seeker sees in the Self, ‘He am I.’

This is the famous ‘That Thou Art’ of the Upanishads. Not the mantra ‘I am Brahman’ practised at the psychological level by many, but the deeper realization of the true sage.

Once again we find an echo of Buddhism here as the verse uses the ‘Three Fires’ as its obstacles to emancipation. In his commentary, Sri Chinmayananda quotes a saying generally attributed to Shankara, ‘Desire, anger, greed are looters that stand within the body, ready to plunder the Knowledge-Gem - therefore, be vigilant! Be vigilant!’

Shankara ends his poem/hymn with a prayer for the enlightenment of his hearers.

O Devotee of the lotus-feet of the teacher! may you
become liberated soon from samsara. Through the
discipline of the sense-organs and the mind, you will
come to experience the Lord that dwells in your
own heart.

A short biography by John M Evans. Part 1

Followers of our recent series on early Zen masters (See Archives in the sidebar), may be interested in this new session of short biographies on masters of Advaita Vedanta in southern India. Advaita has many similarities with Zen.

In the dark, dissolute days of 8th Century India, the ancient religion of Hind was riven by faction and weakened through moral disintegration. Many Brahmin priests were openly corrupt. The traditional Vedic lore had degraded into superstition and was now a mere excuse for clerical power. Buddhism had spread across the sub-continent as the inheritor of Upanishadic purity and the disdainer of gods. It was time, many thought, for the healing balm of a unifying synthesis.

Shankara (c. 788-820) is perhaps the one Indian metaphysician who can claim comparison with Gautama Buddha in the influence he has had on the philosophy of his countrymen. Ostensibly, he lived for only thirty-two years. If that is so his achievement is the more remarkable. Today he is associated with the non-dual religious practices of Advaita Vedanta, which evolved from the Upanishads, a later development of the ancient Vedas hymn/scriptures.

Vedanta (meaning the end of the Vedas) is the basis for most modern Hindu thought. It has two separate, yet interlinked, offshoots, one a dualism known as Sankhya; and Advaita, meaning non-dual. Shankara was numbered in the latter camp.

Shankara is perhaps best known for his tale of the snake and the rope. This simple analogue depicts Brahman (the rope) and man’s illusory response to it (the snake).

The story begins with a man making his way through the jungle at dusk, hoping to reach home before dark. At this time there are many wild animal and insect sounds, even the the roar of a tiger and the almost-silent cheetah.

The man’s state of mind is far from tranquil. As his path approaches a large, shadowy banyan tree, he notices something dangling from one of the branches. This region is notorious for its many deadly cobras and puff adders. He freezes, hardly able to move. Behind him comes the sound of a big cat on the prowl. Caught between the two dangers he crouches beneath a nearby bush, shaking in terror, and certain that a horrible death awaits him that night.

As the dawn starts to break in the East, the first glimmers of light pick out the moist branches of the jungle canopy. The animal sounds have long since ceased and the birds are beginning to get about their business. Shivering with the cold, the man crawls out from beneath the bush scarcely knowing where he is. As he wearily raises his head, he notices a piece of rope hanging from an old banyan tree.

It seems that Shankara was fond of presenting his arguments in parable form, as had the Buddhists in the days before the Hindu revival. This particular story illustrates the Advaita view of the world — ‘God alone is real’ — which is very similar to Zen, by showing God (Brahman) as the rope, or reality, and the world as the snake, or delusion. The snake is what is technically known as a superimposition (adhyasa) caused by ignorance, which the frightened man projects onto the rope, thus veiling its true nature.

The upshot of this is that, while the snake is obviously not real, the rope certainly is. It is the true reality. The world (snake) is therefore a manifestation of the rope (Brahman), which can only be removed by a close enquiry into the existence of the snake. This enquiry reveals the absence of the snake and the presence of the rope.

Next : Part 2 — Shankara’s thought.

In 19th Century America, Ralph Waldo Emerson knew all about the non-dual vision.

“Standing on the bare ground — my head bathed by the blithe air and uplifted into infinite space — all mean egotism vanishes. I become a transparent eyeball; I am nothing; I see all; the currents of the Universal Being circulate through me; I am part and parcel of God.”

Perhaps the most accessible of the Upanishads propounding the non-dual vision is the Katha Upanishad. This scripture describes how a youth, Nachiketas, sacrifices himself to Yama, the God of Death, in order to discover the secrets of immortality. The god grants him three boons which Nachiketas uses to extract the innermost secrets of the universe. In the process he rejects all offers of material powers and pleasure, prompting the god to name the ultimate fire sacrifice after Nachiketas himself.

The story is fascinating in that it has some parallels with the early experiences of the youthful Ramana Maharshi of South India who, at the age of sixteen, was confronted with death in the form of an existential seizure. Instead of collapsing in terror, Ramana boldly faced up to it and extracted the inner essence of the life/death experience.

Apart from the Upanishads, the other major work which constitutes the bedrock of Vedanta and, for that matter, all else in Hindu India, is the Bhagavad Gita. This sublime scripture, sometimes regarded as an Upanishad, has a more practical edge than many other texts of this period. For this reason it is often seen as a work of karma yoga (union through action).

In fact, the jnani (a man of vision or knowledge), is given the prominent place in the scripture. “The jnani and I are one,” says Krishna, the embodiment of God in the Gita.

Nevertheless, the bhakti (devotee) finds his consolation in the Bhagavad Gita, and Mahatma Gandhi used it as authority for his particular gospel of action and work in the world. Like many other great scriptural outpourings, the Gita satisfies all manner of persons.

The book, as we now know it, comes down to us as part of the Mahabharata, a vast epic poem of war and conflict, said to be the longest in the world. The Gita, however, stands out from it, almost as the New Testament shines out of the Bible against the darker qualities of the Old, where “an eye for an eye” becomes “turning the other cheek”.

The spirit of the Gita, as with the Upanishads, can be represented by a few short extracts. The non-duality of the work as a whole is expressed perfectly by Krishna’s words to Arjuna.

‘When a man sees that the God in himself is the same God in all that is, he hurts not himself by hurting others; then he goes to the highest path.”

Again, in a great declaration, Krishna speaks for the All.

I am the Father of this universe, and even the Source
of the Father. I am the Mother of this universe, and
the Creator of all. I am the highest to be known, the
Path of purification … I am the Way, and the Master who
watches in silence; thy friend and shelter and thy
abode of peace. I am the beginning and the middle and
the end of all things: their seed of Eternity, their
Treasure supreme.

From these deeply spiritual teachings, arose Buddhism, Jainism and later a Hindu/Buddhist synthesis, the Advaita Vedanta of Shankara.

We have just launched a new website in our spiritual series, MetaSyntagma. Called Arunachala Spirit it will be blogged directly from the mystical mountain itself by Meenakshi Mammi, who lives on the spot.

Meenakshi writes :

“I am writing to you from Arunachala, South India. We are located about 150 kms from Chennai (Madras) in the agricultural heartland of Tamil Nadu.

“I would like to welcome you to Arunachala Spirit, a blog which will attempt to convey some part of the magic and mystery of Arunachala, one of the most famous sacred sites in India. This is a place of which ancient legends and reports tell of miraculous happenings where the sick are healed, prophets see visions, deities appear, pilgrims get wishes fulfilled and sages attain spiritual enlightenment.”

I believe this is definitely one to follow.

John